Indexed Annuities
The Unique Appeal of Indexed Annuities
Indexed
annuities (IAs) combine most of the features of traditional
fixed annuities with the potential to earn
interest
based on the upward movement of an equity index. Because of
this unique combination of benefits, IAs
have become
very popular among financial consumers. The most common Index
used is the S&P 500 Price Index.
Some products
measure gains on other indices such as the Dow Jones (DJIA),
NASDAQ, etc.
However,
it's important to understand that while IAs offer to credit
interest
at a rate that is linked to the upward movement of a particular
index, IAs are not considered to be securities, and buying an
IA is not the same as buying an investment in the stock market.
This booklet should be used as an aid in helping you decide
if an IA may be right for you. This booklet will help describe
what IAs are and what they are not.
What
is an Indexed Annuity or IA?
IAs are annuities. There are many different types of annuities,
but they all have the following features in common:
-
An annuity is a contract. A contract is an agreement between
an individual and an insurance company. The terms of the
agreement are spelled out in a document called the policy.
-
All annuities involve an individual paying some amount or
amounts of money (referred to as "purchase premium" or "
premium") to an
insurance company and later getting money back from the
company in one form or another, usually either in a lump
sum or stream of income
payments.
-
The individual has a number of options for receiving money
back from the insurance company. One feature that makes
annuities unique among
financial vehicles is that the individual can choose to
receive a regular income that can be guaranteed to last
as long as he or she lives.
-
Because the individual can name a beneficiary to receive
annuity values in the event of his or her death, annuity
values need not become part
of the individual's probate estate but can pass to the beneficiary
free of probate's costs and delays.
With most
annuities, it is anticipated that many years may go by before
the individual will choose to begin receiving income. The period
prior to the time income payments begin is called the "deferral
period", and annuities that have a deferral period are known
as "deferred annuitiesâ€.
During the
deferral period, the premium paid to the company has the potential
to accumulate earnings and grow to a greater sum than was paid
by the individual. To encourage the use of deferred annuities
as long-term savings vehicles, annuity earnings are subject
to special income tax treatment. As long as the accumulations
stay in the annuity, they are not taxed. However, if they are
removed from the annuity before the individual is 591/2, then
in addition to the regular income tax, they are also subject
to an IRS imposed 10% penalty tax unless the individual dies,
has become disabled, or takes equal payments based on life expectancy.
Different
types of annuities use different methods of crediting accumulated
interest to policy values. From an interest-crediting standpoint,
indexed annuities are generally considered to be a type of fixed
annuity, with an important difference from traditional fixed
annuities. To make the significance of that difference clear,
let's begin by looking at traditional fixed annuities
TRADITIONAL
FIXED ANNUITIES
-
The
policy specifies a guaranteed minimum interest rate, or
floor rate, that remains in effect as long as the policy
is in force.
-
In terms
of their accumulation features, traditional fixed annuities
have the following characteristics:
-
Annuity
values are supported by the full faith and credit of the
insurance company.
-
In addition,
the company declares a current rate of interest that may
be in excess of the guaranteed rate or floor rate. This
current rate may be guaranteed to stay in effect for one
or more years.
-
At the
end of that time, the company declares a new current interest
rate, or "renewal" rate, which may be higher or lower than
the previous rate, but not below the minimum interest rate
guaranteed by the policy.
IINDEXED ANNUITIES
As mentioned,
indexed annuities are considered to be a type of fixed annuity.
Indexed annuity values, like
traditional
fixed annuity values, are backed by the full faith and credit
of the insurance company and a minimum guaranteed interest rate
is specified in the policy.
Where IAs
differ from traditional fixed annuities is in the method of
determining the current interest rate to credit to annuity values.
Instead of declaring a specific rate, as is done with traditional
fixed annuities, the company issuing an indexed annuity states
that it will credit interest based on the change in value of
a specified equity index.
While the
insurance company doesn't specify a current interest rate, it
does specify the formula for determining the interest rate with
reference to that equity index. Because no one knows what will
happen to the level of the index, the interest rate to be credited
to annuity values cannot be known in advance. Only the minimum
contract guarantee is known in advance.
The advantage
to an IA contract is two-fold: (1) If the index moves up, you
win and earn a higher interest rate. (2) If the index moves
down, you are protected by the minimum contract guarantee. "Heads
you win; tails you break even." You are allowed to participate
in a portion of the upside potential of the market with limited
downside risk.
Important IA Terminology
When it
comes to the formulas used by insurance companies to determine
the interest rate credited to their IA policies, no two are
exactly alike. However, being familiar with the important IA
terminology explained in this section will help you obtain a
better understanding of any IA you may be considering.
TERM
The time
period for which certain features of an I A are designed to
be in effect. At the end of a term, the annuity owner usually
has the option to renew for another term or take the full-accumulated
value penalty free. Typically, surrender charges are imposed
on withdrawals or surrenders during the term, although there
may be certain exceptions. Common terms for IAs range between
five and ten years.
PARTICIPATION RATE
The percentage
of the measured increase in the index that will be credited
to an IAs policy value. For example, if an IA has a participation
rate of 75%, and the increase in the index is measured to be
10%, the interest credited to the IAs account value will be
7.5% (75% of 10%). The participation rate is also called the
"index rate" for some IAs. Simply put, the client will participate
in a portion of the index gains.
How IAs Differ From Index
Mutual Funds
"Index investing" has become popular with equity
investors
in recent years. Instead of trying to pick high-performing
stocks based on various measures of value, index
investors
simply purchase shares of a mutual fund, which
is
composed of all the stocks that belong to a
particular equity index.
However, while index investing and IAs both
make reference to an equity index, purchasing
an IA is very different from purchasing shares
in an index mutual fund.
For example, an IA cannot provide the entire
value of an
upward movement in an index to an IA owner.
The reason
for this is that part of the IA premium must
be invested in a
manner that will support the IAs minimum guarantees.
In
addition, IAs measure only the level of the
price index itself,
which does not include the value of dividends.
Subject to the claims-paying ability of the
insurance
company issuing the IA, the IA principal is
protected against market loss. IA owners may
lose principal to surrender
charges if they withdraw funds before the end
of the
term, but if they hold their IA to term, they
will receive the greater of their original premium
or the minimum
guaranteed cash value, even if the index has
declined. Generally, index mutual funds provide
no such guarantees. Also, some IAs lock in interest
credits based on index increases even if the
index later declines. With index mutual
funds, gains in value can be lost if the index
later declines.
|
Issuers
of IAs generally reserve the right to change the participation
rate at specified intervals. Some IAs have participation rates
that are guaranteed to remain the same for the entire term.
Some IAs have participation rates that may change each year.
The participation
rates of various IA products should not be compared without
also considering the method used to measure increases in the
index (discussed later under "Index Growth"). There are different
ways to measure the increase in the index, and some of these
methods may tend to produce higher results than others, depending
on how the level of the index changes. Index growth measurement
methods perform differently in different market environments.
It is the
combination of the participation rate and the measured increase
in the index that produces the interest rate credited to IA
policy values. So you need to know how increases in the index
are measured as well as the applied participation rate in order
to understand how interest credits are determined for a particular
IA. Because every IA product has the potential for multiple
"moving parts" it is important to understand your product. True
"apples to apples" product comparison cannot be achieved without
knowing all the "moving partsâ€.
ADMINISTRATION FEE OR SPREAD
This is
a fixed percentage deducted from any increase measured in the
index. Many IAs do not have an administration fee. Some IAs
use an administration fee instead of a participation rate. An
administration fee is sometimes called the "Spread Yield "or"
Spread." For example, if an IA has a Spread Yield of 2.5%, and
the increase in the index is measured to be 10%, the interest
credited to the IA's account value will be 7.5% (10% minus 2.5%).
It is important to note in what order the deductions are taken
to ensure an accurate comparison.
CAP
Some IAs
place a limit on the percentage of interest that will be credited
to the policy value. This limit is known as the cap. Since it
is expressed as a percentage, it may be called the†cap rate."
Any gains earned that exceed the stated cap will not be credited
to the policy.
FLOOR
This is
the minimum index linked interest rate that will be credited
to the policy value regardless of how the index performs. All
IAs have a floor. For some IAs, the floor can be as low as 0%.
It should be noted that minimum guarantees (see next item) are
generally calculated separately from the index based interest
calculation and are based on performance over the life of the
contract and not on a policy year basis.
CONTRACT
VALUE
An IA's
minimum guaranteed cash value, sometimes called the reference
value or guaranteed policy value.
INDEX GROWTH
The measured
increase in the index for a given period of time also, referred
to as the index increase.
As mentioned
earlier, different IAs use different methods of measuring index
growth. Following are descriptions of the major ways various
IAs measure index growth, though certain IAs may employ variations
on these themes. Measuring methods can include, but will not
be limited to:
Point-to-Point:
Some IAs measure index growth by comparing the level of the
index at the
beginning of the term with the level of the index at the end
of the term. The length of the term can vary. This is usually
referred to as the “point-to-point" method.
High Water:
Some IAs
measure index growth by comparing the level of the index at
the beginning of the term with the level of the index on the
policy anniversary where it was highest. This is usually referred
to as the “high-water mark" method.
Annual Reset:
Some
IAs measure index growth year by year, resetting the index's starting
point for measuring purposes at the level where it stood at the
beginning of each year. This is usually referred to as the “annual
reset" method.
Each of the
methods may or may not include averaging. Some IAs use an average
measure of index growth by adding together the index's value at
the close of each business day during a given time period and then
dividing by the number of days, or adding together the index's value
at the close of each month and then dividing by the number of months.
This is usually referred to as the “averaging" method. Averaging
for all or a major portion of the measuring period may tend to produce
lower index increases if the index has increased fairly steadily
between measuring points and higher index increases if the index
has risen and then fallen substantially between measuring points.
Recently, a
handful of carriers have designed contracts with new crediting methods
to measure the index growth:
Binary
Reset:
These IAs
will pay a stated rate as long as the index returns to equal
the beginning value or greater at the end of the reset period.
Low Water:
These IAs
take the lowest anniversary value and allow that to become the
beginning index value from the beginning of the contract.
Term High
Average Anniversary:
These IAs take a rolling annual average of the monthly index
values and use highest annual average as the end point.
Fixed
Rate with Equity Function:
There are two variations of this IA on the market. The first
credits a fixed rate to an amount of the premium and the rest
participates in the index using an annual reset crediting method.
The second credits a fixed rate and also a portion of the term
end gains.
Bond Linked:
These IAs
are linked to US Treasury Notes. An initial rate is set at issue
and if the T-note rate is greater at the anniversary, the client
will receive the higher rate for the next renewal period. If
the T-note rate is lower at the anniversary, the client's rate
will be decreased accordingly, but never lower than the initial
rate
Monthly
Cap:
These IAs
calculate the index gain over the crediting period by adding
each month's gains and losses together. The monthly gains are
subject to a cap rate and the crediting period interest cannot
be lower than zero.
While each
of these measuring methods will produce different results, the
one which produces the best result depends on how the index
changes during the term of the policy. Since no one can predict
how the index will change, it isn't possible to say in advance
which method of measuring index growth will produce the greatest
increase. The "best" method is the one a particular IA owner
is most comfortable with, no matter what changes occur to the
level of the index. That is why it is very important to read
and understand any IA you are considering.
INDEX INTEREST
The amount
of interest credited to an IAs policy value. Index interest
is sometimes referred to as index earnings. As mentioned earlier,
multiplying index growth by the participation rate or subtracting
the spread yield, or both, calculates index interest.
RENEWAL
At the end
of a term, the owner of an IA may be given the opportunity to
renew the IA for another term. In effect, renewal means using
the existing IA fund as the premium to purchase another IA of
the same type. If the owner does not wish to renew, he or she
has other options, which could include but are not limited to:
-
Exchange
the IA for another type of annuity;
-
Surrender
the IA for its cash value; or
-
Convert
the IA to a stream of income payments.
These options
may also be exercised during the term, but in some cases, surrender
charges may apply. Many IAs provide a "windowâ€, for example
30 or 45 days at the end of a term, during which these options
may be exercised without incurring surrender charges-however,
the government-imposed 10% penalty tax may still apply if the
owner is under age 59%.
WITHDRAWALS
Most IAs
allow their owners to take money out of their annuity without
surrendering the contract, but the terms under which this may
be done vary from policy to policy. Read your policy carefully.
In many cases, IA owners incur a cost to make a withdrawal.
This often takes the form of a surrender charge, which is usually
calculated as a percentage of the amount withdrawn. With some
IAs, withdrawal charges may be waived under certain circumstances
- if the amount withdrawn is less than 10% of the annuity's
value, or if the owner has been confined to a nursing home,
for example.
Withdrawals
can reduce the amount of index interest credited to an IA. If
money is withdrawn prior to a measuring point, generally no
credit is given for the time the money stays in the policy.
Also,
an IA owner's access to index credits can be affected by the
method used to measure index growth. For example, under the
point-to-point method, index interest is credited at the end
of the policy term, so there
is no index
interest to withdraw prior to the end of the term. Under other
methods, index interest may be credited to an IA policy periodically
during the policy term. Some policies provide access to these
amounts via free withdrawals, while others may effectively limit
the amount a policy owner can withdraw by imposing vesting requirements
or surrender charges.
In general,
any annuity - including an IA - should be considered a long-term
savings vehicle. You shouldn't put money into an IA that you
expect to need before the end of the policy term. The purpose
of withdrawal provisions is to provide some flexibility in case
an unforeseen emergency arises. In deciding among different
IAs, you may find trade-offs between the liberality of withdrawal
provisions and the formulas for calculating interest credits.
That is, IAs that offer the greatest potential for interest
earnings may be relatively more restricted in terms of withdrawals,
and vice versa. Look for an IA that provides a combination of
withdrawal provisions and interest crediting potential that
seems most comfortable for you.
Are Indexed Annuities Right For You?
Whether
an IA is right for you is a question only you can answer after
consulting with your financial advisors. However, there are
some characteristics that should generally apply to anyone who
is considering the purchase of an IA.
An IA may be right for you if:
-
You
are looking for a long-term savings vehicle and don't expect
to need the money you would put into an IA until the end
of the term.
-
You are comfortable with a varying interest rate that will
be credited to your funds, as long as it is subject to a
guaranteed minimum and offers
the potential (but no guarantee) of being higher than those
offered on traditional fixed-rate savings vehicles.
-
You want to earn interest at a rate linked to increases
in an equity index and are willing to forego full participation
in the index in return for the principal and minimum interest
guarantees associated with fixed annuities.
An Answer For The Risk-Averse Saver
According
to a study performed by DALBAR, Inc. (Quantitative Analysis
of Investor Behavior, 1994), the 10-year performance of the
Standard & Poor's 500 equity index between January 1984 and
September 1993 was 293%.Yet during the same period, the average
equity mutual fund investor made only 70%.
The reason
for the difference was this: in order to realize the 293% return,
an investor had to "buy and hold" over the entire 10-year period.
Unfortunately, many investors do not buy and hold. When the
market goes down, they take their money out, hoping to avoid
further losses. While their money is out, they miss many of
the market's upswings.
This behavior
occurs because of risk-aversion. In trying to avoid losses,
risk-averse financial consumers may actually prevent themselves
from realizing the gains they seek.
IAs allow
risk-averse savers the opportunity to earn a rate of interest
linked to equity performance without fearing loss of principal
due to market fluctuations, as long as they hold their IAs to
term. IA owners need not withdraw their money from their policies
during market downturns for fear of incurring losses - they
can feel reassured by the fixed annuity's minimum guarantees.
They can keep their money in the policy until the markets turn
back up, at which point they stand to earn potentially higher
rates of interest linked to increases in the equity index.
any product or security in any state or other jurisdiction. The
insurance polices described are issued by various companies. They
are not available in all states. Policy terms, conditions and limitations
will apply. Not all applicants will qualify for coverage. You can
obtain more information about these products and services by contacting
your insurance agent. West Financial Services or BISYS makes no
representation regarding the suitability of
these products to your needs. Neither BISYS nor the insurance carriers
provide tax or legal advice regarding these programs. You should
consult your own tax, legal and other advisors before purchasing
these
products.07.05
ANN.045.1
Want
more information?
Email Us With your Question